CORRUPTION-NEPAL: All the King's Men Try to Fix a Broken Humpty Dumpty

By Suman Pradhan

KATHMANDU, Apr 27 (IPS) - In the wee hours of Wednesday several jeep-loads of heavily armed policemen arrived at the residence of former Nepalese prime minister Sher Bahadur Deuba. He was packed into one of the vehicles and driven away - arrested on charges of corruption.

As the police jeeps drove away with the former prime minister, it became clear just how polarised Nepal has become over the issue of corruption, especially after King Gyanendra dismissed the Deuba government on Feb. 1 and seized complete political power.

Corruption was once the biggest issue worrying Nepali voters. But today, it has been turned into a politically charged issue - thanks to the machinations of the new autocratic regime. In its zeal to only charge democratic politicians for corruption and abuse of authority, the regime has ironically managed to create the inevitable impression that it is settling old scores.

'People today have a lot of sympathy for these politicians even if they are corrupt because the government has mishandled the issue,' said Ram Sharma (name changed), a political analyst with a donor agency in Kathmandu. 'They (the royal regime) have shown a remarkable lack of political acumen while pursuing these cases.'

No one doubts that Nepal's politicians deserve the attention of anti-corruption agencies. No one, not even politicians, deny that the freewheeling democratic years from 1990 to 2002 were characterised by massive corruption in government ranks.

Leaders who were voted into office because of their honest and simple lifestyles were soon driving expensive Pajero jeeps in a matter of years. Leftover cash was invested in major private businesses away from the prying eyes of the public.

A poll funded by the U.S.-based National Democratic Institute late last year found that most Nepalis were deeply concerned by corruption issues and wanted political parties to deal with it effectively. But the parties dithered, afraid that tackling corrupt leaders would fracture the whole multi-party democratic process.

But after he seized power, King Gyanendra had no such concerns.

Announcing corruption as one of the major scourges, he formed a Royal Corruption Control Commission (RCCC) in February, just after seizing absolute power. The all- powerful RCCC has the mandate to probe, prosecute and sentence offenders - a power so great that it turns natural justice on its head, legal experts allege.

In a remarkable lack of political sense, the king packed the commission with old royal hands who had served in an era of absolute monarchy started by Gyanendra's father - King Mahendra – in 1960. That era was dismantled by a popular movement in 1990, when pro-democracy demonstrators forced Gyanendra's brother - King Birendra Bir Bikram Shah - to relegate his authority to that of a constitutional monarch.

Nonetheless, all the gains made in 1990 were dismantled by the royal coup on Feb. 1.

One of the RCCC's first task was to probe financial improprieties in the last Deuba government. Several ministers were summoned, questioned and released on bail for disbursing public funds to political activists last year during the holy Dasain festival, which falls in autumn. Allegedly, all the former ministers who gave out the money happened to belong to democratic political parties.

Then the RCCC put its hands in a controversial drinking water project - the 464 million U.S. dollar Melamchi drinking water project - financed, among others, by the Asian Development Bank (AsDB).

Early this month, it summoned Prakash Man Singh, a former minister for physical planning and leader of Deuba's Nepali Congress (Democratic), to answer why he had cancelled an old contract to build a 23-kilometre road leading to the project site and given it to a Chinese-Nepali joint venture instead. Singh refused to appear before the RCCC.

'This is a political witch hunt,' Singh said early last week. 'The decision was made in accordance with the law and there is no corruption involved. Besides, I refuse to appear before a commission which is unconstitutional.'

That got him into jail. Late last week, after the deadline for him to appear before the RCCC expired, police swiftly bundled Singh into a van from his house and threw him in a lockup. The RCCC has extended his detention by seven more days to finish its investigation.

Deuba's arrest will be at a huge political cost to the RCCC. That is because of the public’s perception that the royal commission is being used as political tool to settle old scores.

'No one says our politicians are clean. But so is the case with the king's supporters. They did more corruption during the 30-year rule under absolute monarchy than these guys. Why does not the RCCC go after them?' asks Bikram Lama, a taxi driver in Kathmandu.

The Asian Development Bank itself has further bolstered the politicians' case. 'The Kathmandu Post' newspaper reported Tuesday that AsDB officials had themselves approved of the contractor change in the Melamchi drinking water project.

'The approval was undertaken according to AsDB procedures,' the newspaper reported a bank official as saying. The previous contract was cancelled, the official was quoted as saying, 'due to gross under-performance.' The RCCC has yet to react to the AsDB's claims, but the damage has been done.

Also, it does not help that the RCCC is openly encroaching into a jurisdictional area of the constitutionally empowered Commission for Investigation of Abuse of Authority (CIAA). Officials there privately lament the RCCC's role and say the royal body is giving a bad name to the anti-corruption investigations.

'Even in those cases we're looking after, the RCCC has interfered in. But what can we do? It is the king's commission and he is all-powerful,' decries a CIAA investigating officer.

But the RCCC has given every indication that it doesn't give a damn.

On Apr. 21, it issued fresh orders to Nepal's banks to furnish the financial records of over 100 selected politicians and bureaucrats. None of those names belong to loyal royals. (END/2005)

Deuba gets jail term on corruption charge

KATHMANDU, JULY 26 The Royal Commission for Corruption Control (RCCC) on Tuesday awarded a two-year jail term and a Rs 90 million ($1.3 million) fine each to former Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba and former minister Prakash Man Singh, holding them guilty of embezzling $5.3 million in the multi-billion Melamchi drinking water project.

RCCC chairman Bhakta Bahadur Koirala handed out the sentences. The Commission was appointed by King Gyanendra, with sweeping powers to try cases of corruption in high offices.

Singh was the Physical Planning minister in Deuba’s cabinet when it awarded the contract for a $464 million drinking water project—funded by the Asian Development Bank (ADB)—to a Chinese company with local partners.

The Commission also convicted the former secretary to the government, besides the executive and deputy executive director of the Melamchi Drinking Water Project, handing out a year’s jail term and a Rs 45 million fine to each.

Sources in Deuba’s family said both Deuba and Singh would challenge the verdict in the supreme court.

Incidentally, the RCC verdict was delivered three days after the integrity committee of ADB—the lead donor of the project—informed the Commission that there was no irregularity or corruption in the project. The Norwegian government—which had provided Rs 180 million for the project—announced its withdrawal, criticising the Royal regime for harassing its political rivals.

ADB says it will pull out from Melamchi

Do you think Sher Bahadur Deuba should be punished or hanged in public?

mm,

keep up the good work for bringing awareness. these are the bitter truths of impoverished Nepal.

Deuba et.al should be burned alive.