[Show all top banners]

confused_soul
Replies to this thread:

More by confused_soul
What people are reading
Subscribers
:: Subscribe
Back to: Kurakani General Refresh page to view new replies
 History book revisted :Everybody must read

[Please view other pages to see the rest of the postings. Total posts: 27]
PAGE: <<  1 2  
[VIEWED 17607 TIMES]
SAVE! for ease of future access.
The postings in this thread span 2 pages, go to PAGE 1.

This page is only showing last 20 replies
Posted on 01-11-10 4:57 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     1       ?     Liked by
 

      An  account  by  Austrian journalist, Dr. Hans Georg Behr  in his book titled “Nepal Geschenk der Götter  (Nepal  Gifts  of  the  Gods)” written  in  German  reveals  an unknown  part  of  our  history  how the  Newah  Kingdoms  fallen  to Gurkhas. The account by Dr. Behr, who  was  born  in  Vienna,  Austria but  lives  in  Hamburg,  Germany, translated into English by Chakana Nepahmi and a Nepal Bhasa version by Binod Saymi  “Ala” have brought these untold episodes of  the history  into  light recently. Either many of our historians were not aware of  the episodes or reluctant  to convey  to us  the events what led to the fall of Newah kingdoms in the Nepal Mandala in the 18th  century. The account  therein  contradicts  the  conventional account of unification story of Nepal.


Hamburg, Germany - Since 1716, Gorkha’s (ruler) Narabhupal Shah had
been  sitting  on  his  throne  made  of   mud.  He  found  his  throne  very
uncomfortable,  and wanted  to  change  it  with  the  silver  throne  of   the
Kathmandu Valley  at  any  cost. With  this  aim  in mind,  he married many
times  to widen his  territory and built alliances. But he was not successful
At  the  end,  he  changed  his  tactics.  In  1732,  he  sent  his  10  year  old  son
Prithvi Narayan  to  stay with  the  king  of  Bhaktapur  (Ranajit Malla).  In  a
covering  letter, Narabhupal Shah  requested  the king of  Bhaktapur  to  raise
his  son  and  provide  him  a  good  education  which  was  only  possible  in
Nepal. But his  real  intention was  to place his son  in  the palace so  that he
could spy on  it and gather vital  information. The Malla king of  Bhaktapur
took in this young prince of  Gorkha with friendship and treated him as the
guest. Prithvi Narayan Shah had an excellent memory that he remembered
everything he saw. After  five years, he  returned  to his hometown Gorkha
He had gathered much  information about  the  reasons behind  the quarrels
among  the valley kings,  the exact quantity of  military equipments and  the
strategic locations in Nepal.
Prithvi  Narayan  Shah  was  sure  that  he  could  conquer  the  pass  of
Nuwakot,  so  in  the  same  year  he  sent  his  Gorkha  soldiers  to  attack
Nuwakot. The      young    prince    had    miscalculated or    his father had 
 underestimated  the  Mallas.  The  Malla  kings  banded  together  and  their
armies beat the Gorkhas very badly.
Since  then,  the Gorkha  launched  an  attack  on  the  valley  every  year
right after the monsoon in order to possess its wealth. But they were failed.
The Gorkhas  came  punctually  at  the  end  of   September,  but  they  never
made any headway. This went on till 1764.  Prithvi then sent a peace message
 to the valley. The Mallas received his message with joy. The endless war was
 a strain on their resources, and it was also disrupting  their  business. 
But Prithvi Narayan  Shah’s message  was  a clever deception; he really
didn’t seek peace. The Mallas came to know that it  was  only  a  ploy 
when  the Gorkhas  blocked  the  northern  trade  route.
Another thing that worried the Mallas was that the Gorkhas had come into
possessions of  excellent arms and  lots of  money with which  to prosecute
the war. The Mallas didn’t know from where the Gorkhas had got them.
The  British  government  had  supplied  the weapons  to  the Gorkhas,
but  this  fact  has  been  kept  hidden  in Nepal’s  history  books.  The  secret
treaty which was signed is still preserved in London in the archives of  East
Indian Company. The pact was signed by Captain Ceane and the Gorkhas.
The British government  agreed  to  supply  the weapons and  advice;  and  in
return, the Gorkhas had to destroy the old trade routes between India and
China. The Moguls of  India had a flourishing business relationship with the
Mallas of  Nepal, and this trade accounted for 30 percent of  the wealth of 
the Moguls. The British wanted to get their hands on the riches.
        According  to  the accord, Prithvi Narayan Shah  received 800 muskets
along with  21 British  advisors. And  in  1766,  armed with British weapons
and  intelligence,  the  Gorkhas  attacked  Kirtipur.  The  people  of   Kirtipur
could not resist the superior arms, and two third of  them were killed. The
cruel Gorkhas  cut off   the noses of   the  survivors. Till  today,  this place  is
known as  the “Village of   the noseless”. The Mallas  then  realized  that  the
situation had become precarious.
Jaya Prakash Malla,  the king of  Kathmandu, was  an  intelligent  ruler.
He wrote  a very  touching  letter  to  the East  India Company  appealing  for
assistance against the Gorkhas. The East India Company subsequently sent
15  very  strong men  under  the  command  of   a  captain  named Kinlock  to
help the Mallas. This captain was quite fond of  drinking alcohol. When the
British arrived at the hills leading to the Kathmandu valley, they faked being
defeated  by  the Gorkhas.  The Gorkhas  pretended  to  hit  them  and  they
acted as  if   they were wounded.  (Like we say  in Nepal Bhasa “Chhan daye
then ya, jin khwaya then yaye.”)The British wanted the Mallas to think that
the Gorkhas were too powerful to fight with.
        Jaya  Prakash Malla  then  looked  to  religion  for  support. A  priest  he
trusted  told  the  king  that  the  future  of  Nepal  depended  on  the Kumari
(Living Goddess). And so in 1768, the festival of  Indra Jatra was celebrated
with  fervour.  The  Nepalese  (the  Newar  people)  drank lots  of   rice  beer
during the festivities, especially on September 13 on the day of  the chariot
festival. They did not notice that the Gorkhas had entered the city until they
had surrounded the Kumari’s chariot.  
 Pandemonium broke out  that  Jaya Prakash Malla  jumped down  from
the  royal  chariot  with  his  two  wives  and  escaped  to  Lalitpur.  Prithv
Narayan Shah stepped in front of  the bewildered crowd and shouted, “I’m
now your king. Carry on with your drinking.” Prithvi Narayan Shah was a
that time 46 years old.
        Many Newars drank  rice beer because  they were  terror-stricken. Th
Gorkhas put their swords to the necks of  the Newars who refused to     accept  the  new  king,  so  they  had no choice but to obey. In  the  following  winter,  the Gorkhas  also  conquered  Lalitpur
without  any  opposition.  The Mallas  then  gathered  at  the  palace in Bhaktapur. The  palace was well defended.  And  following  the advice  of   his  British  advisors, Prithvi  Narayan  Shah  imposed  a blockade.   After  three  years, Bhaktapur’s food stock ran out. And one night, some  illegitimate  children  of   the Mallas opened the gates to the city. The  valley’s  three  kings  were arrested  in  their  bedrooms.  Jaya Prakash  Malla  committed  suicide. To  show  his  big-heartedness,
Prithvi  Narayan  allowed  Jaya Prakash  to  be  brought  to Pashupatinath for the final rites.
        Bhaktapur’s  king  Ranajit Malla,  who  had  given  shelter  to Prithvi  Narayan,  was  not  killed;
instead  his  eyes were  blown  up  to blind  and  banished  to  the  Hindu city  of   Benaris.  Tej  Narasingh  of  Patan  did  not  want  to  exchange any  words  with  Prithvi  Narayan. Tej Narasingh was  imprisoned  in a vault  and walled  up. A  small  hole was  left open  to pass food to him.
And  for  two  days,  a  bowl  of   rice was  left  near  the  hole. When  they saw  that  Tej  Narasingh  had  not touched  the  food,  the  hole  was bricked up. Prithvi  Narayan  Shah  did everything  according  to  Captain Ceane’s  suggestions.  He  said  to Prithvi  Narayan,  “The  people  of 
Nepal  are  very  hard  working  and intelligent.  That  is  why  they  are very  dangerous. We  need  to  strike terror  into  their hearts  in order  to control  them.  Do  not  let  them come  to  power  even  after  many   centuries.  We  need  to  obliterate from their minds the idea of  rising up to seize power. This can only be achieved  through  harsh  laws  and violence.”

   Accordingly, Newars were  not  allowed  to  read, write  or  repair  their
houses.  If   they broke  the  law,  they  faced  the dealth penalty.  In 1770,  two
and  half   thousand  Newars  were  killed.  The  second  generation  was
thoroughly intimidated, and gave up. The third generation started to forget.
After Prithvi Narayan Shah took control of  the valley, the old cities began
to stagnate even though so much money was pouring into the country. The
only changes in the cityscape that occured were the result of  earthquakes.  
The British naturally benefitted greatly from their cruel plan. In 1776,
the Mogul Empire became bankrupt and was forced to become a colony of 
Britain. The whole of  central Asia suffered after Prithvi Narayan Shah took
over  Nepal  and  closed  the  old  trade  routes.  Tibet’s  economy  too  was
negatively affected. The depressed economy forced monasteries to become
financially self-reliant. This was how feudalism emerged as a shadow in the
land of  the Buddha. There was a negative effect even in China.
 The British were also not very happy with the Gorkhas. The Gorkhas
had  tasted  the  blood,  and  did  not  give  up  violence.  In  this  way,  they
conquered  all  the  hill  states.  The  Gorkha  turned  the  country  into  a
“forbidden  land”. As  long  as  the  country  remained  closed up,  the British
were  not  disturbed. But  in  1789,  the Gorkhas  became  crazy  and went  to
war with China and England.
Britain’s General Ochterlony said, “We have to keep the Gorkhas busy
so that other things besides conquest come to their minds.” Lord Hastings
wrote in his diary in 1817, “To bring peace in Nepal, the Gorkhas must be
kept busy and far from their country.” This policy led to the recruitment of 
Gorkha  soldiers  into British  army. The Nepal government  took one-third
of   the money  sent home by  the Gorkhas.  It was  an  important  source of 
income for the government of  Nepal.
        After  the  Gorkhas  began  leaving  Nepal,  there  was  peace  on  the
frontier as well as within the country. But  there was no peace  in  the king’s
palace.  The  Shahs  fought  among  themselves.  They  didn’t  care  about  the
country  or  the  people.  They  remained  engrossed  in  their  own  interests.
Then  came  the Kot Parwa,  and  the  Jung Bahadur Rana  took  over power
from the Shah king.

 
The postings in this thread span 2 pages, go to PAGE 1.

This page is only showing last 20 replies
Posted on 01-12-10 3:30 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

source plz?ani k tetra nepali historians le thaha napako kuro yo mula gaustrian bratwurst le kasari thaha payo huh?


k timi pani baje ko gaun khane katha sunaudai chhau solta?


 
Posted on 01-12-10 8:27 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     1       ?     Liked by
 

This is a very funny article. Made my day. Where is the rest of it? Please post more.

 
Posted on 01-12-10 8:37 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     1       ?     Liked by
 

This to me sounds like work of fiction...


 
Posted on 01-12-10 9:24 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

History written without any references or research.. Its like fiction.. it can be a good script for a movie though..
 
Posted on 01-12-10 9:29 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

source of this article: http://www.nepal-lipi.com/cmspdf/56334The%20Newah%20Suppliment%203.pdf


 
Posted on 01-12-10 10:15 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 
 
Posted on 01-12-10 10:19 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     1       ?     Liked by
 

Maobadi le "Peace" ko barema lekheko article jastai raicha!! La newar daju bhai didi baini haru haru badhai cha. Sabaile darcheruwa bhanthe darako haina raicha dherai "Rice wine" kha ko belama jhukkayechan daka harule. Aba history change garnu paryo bhanera 2-4 din banda garaune haina ta????

Hami Nepali harulai bhagawan le satbuddhi deun,
Peace...

 
Posted on 01-12-10 10:41 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

1. Above article looks like mostly hearsay. PNS visit to Bhaktapur was strategic that should be obvious even at the standard of that time. Mallas fail to understand this shows that they were not serious about their states and enjoying wealth. this part is written in the school level history books I think.
2. I tried to Google captain Caene but no success looks like only that Austrian doc, knows about him, you can Google Lord Hasting, Ochterlony and capt. Kinlock but not captain Caene, even though he was doing strategic treaty with Gurkhas against Mallas, funny isnt it?
3.Long before 1776 Mogul empire was collapsed, they were bankrupt because of the British strategy not PNS blocking the trade route, even in  Wikipedia ppl have written how cleverly British East India company  defeated Mogul empire .
4. 30% wealth of Muguls from the trade between Mugals and Ktm valley. Mugals were very rich, 30 of their wealth means a lot of wealth, what KTM valley was importing?? it was a agriculture society, small population and lots of land. so what Mallas imported from Mugals?? Tv, cars?/ Aeroplanes? fighter planes? tank??
5. There was a silk road for trade between China, Central Asia and Europe, never herd of any trade route that passes through Ktm or ends in Ktm, tried to Google but no luck and that thing affected economy of centrail Asia even China?? "Chini pani dherai khayooo vaney tito huncha mitra".
6. This Austrain doc have spent a lot of time in Ktm after 1955 he may have fascinated with hearsay thing without any factual proof.

I do not know why ppl always fascinated with negative side. but what can I do?  there are ppl who praise Hitler and deny holocast, and ppl still love to fed negative thoughts to the society.




 
Posted on 01-12-10 2:40 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

Sounds like German propoganda against British.  Mostly fiction, I would say, comingled with shades of truth.
 
Posted on 01-12-10 2:47 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

The doc is so full of himself. I would like to see his sources... Nice fiction though. If you want to read the true account of what happened, you should read:

http://worldnewahforum.com/AN%20ACCOUNT%20OFTHE%20KINGDOM%20OF%20NEPAL.pdf

Last edited: 12-Jan-10 02:50 PM

 
Posted on 01-13-10 11:18 AM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

I want to buy the English Version of this book but could not find anywhere.

Does anybody have some idea where i can find this book ?

 
Posted on 01-13-10 12:40 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     1       ?     Liked by
 

its a product of confused minds dividing and racist thoughts.
 
Posted on 01-13-10 3:14 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

thanks newlynew!


any other links u have?


 
Posted on 01-15-10 3:43 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

Dear friends,
   This book can be found in Amazon, Unfortunately english translation hasn't been complete yet. Don't ask me for source when I am stating name of the book.
 
Anywez for people who are interested in more history book, U can take a look at this 2

http://www.sajha.com/sajha/html/openthread.cfm?threadid=78609

And please note.. these are not my words. It's the words of writer and just showing it to u guys.

For people who have only read school history books and mahendra mala and all those crap..am sorry..if u r still willing to cling on to this...

take a look at my 2nd series on history books..Hope you will like
Last edited: 15-Jan-10 04:03 PM

 
Posted on 01-15-10 4:10 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

Google nai satya ho...yedi kunai kura Google ma chaina bhane it is lie....Google is the only truth in this world.
Thus, everything else is false.

 
Posted on 01-15-10 4:16 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

this is too long bro cant understand!
 
Posted on 01-16-10 5:19 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

very interesting stuff..I want to read this book.

 
Posted on 01-16-10 8:37 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

Sounds very interesting, logical to some extent but due to lack to credibility, can't just rely fully on this article. We should think critically, if it's true would be a milestone in Nepali History.

P.S. OMG Things that we learnt in Grade 8,9,10 is just a conspiracy ?? WTF (If This is True)

 
Posted on 01-16-10 8:42 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 


^^^
deskbhaktanepali
See this Google Fan :
Just for Fun

 
Posted on 01-16-10 9:43 PM     Reply [Subscribe]
Login in to Rate this Post:     0       ?    
 

The source where this article is found, http://www.nepal-lipi.com/cmspdf/56334The%20Newah%20Suppliment%203.pdf (as stated earlier), and other posts by confused_soul clearly states his intention.
This is not the kind of soul we need to bridge the divide between the Nepali Community. (Not talking about the article but the intention of the originator in general)

 



PAGE: <<  1 2  
Please Log in! to be able to reply! If you don't have a login, please register here.

YOU CAN ALSO



IN ORDER TO POST!




Within last 365 days
Recommended Popular Threads Controvertial Threads
Lets play Antakshari...........
शीर्षक जे पनि हुन सक्छ।
NRN card pros and cons?
What are your first memories of when Nepal Television Began?
TPS Re-registration
Democrats are so sure Trump will win
is Rato Bangala school cheating?
What Happened to Dual Citizenship Bill
Basnet or Basnyat ??
We live in precarious times
H1B fraud
nrn citizenship
इन्दिरा जोशीको चिन्ता लौच
Sajha has turned into MAGATs nest
Nas and The Bokas: Coming to a Night Club near you
श्राद्द
सेक्सी कविता - पार्ट २
डलराँ कमाएर ने .रु मा उडांउदा !@#
ChatSansar.com Naya Nepal Chat
Why always Miss Nepal winner is Newari??
Nas and The Bokas: Coming to a Night Club near you
राजदरबार हत्या काण्ड बारे....
Mr. Dipak Gyawali-ji Talk is Cheap. US sends $ 200 million to Nepal every year.
Harvard Nepali Students Association Blame Israel for hamas terrorist attacks
TPS Update : Jajarkot earthquake
is Rato Bangala school cheating?
NOTE: The opinions here represent the opinions of the individual posters, and not of Sajha.com. It is not possible for sajha.com to monitor all the postings, since sajha.com merely seeks to provide a cyber location for discussing ideas and concerns related to Nepal and the Nepalis. Please send an email to admin@sajha.com using a valid email address if you want any posting to be considered for deletion. Your request will be handled on a one to one basis. Sajha.com is a service please don't abuse it. - Thanks.

Sajha.com Privacy Policy

Like us in Facebook!

↑ Back to Top
free counters